A lot of traders love to trade Futures. Unfortunately most of them play it un-hedged or naked. Futures is highly leveraged derivatives and has a Delta of almost 1. Which means it moves 1 point with every 1 point move in the underlying. Isn’t this trying to take too much of risk? Remember you are leveraging your money.
Whatever, if done well, rewards are amazing. Futures can make you a fortune pretty soon or can take away all your wealth within months. Unlike options where the losers bleed slowly, Futures will bring results pretty fast.
Simple reason is that Futures traders lose a lot of money in 1 or 2 months and then they quit. Option buyers on the other hand bleed slowly. They lose small sums which are not painful, then they get their salary and try again this time for a recovery – lose some more next month by luck they recover some money. Then brokers tell them to keep trying, and after years and years of trading they find that they are deep in red amounting to lakhs. By this time their brokers are running all the way laughing to their banks and the trader stops trading frustrated promising never to return to the stock markets. Money Lost acceptable Time Lost without any meaningful knowledge is not acceptable. But then it gets too late.
Sometimes it gets so bad that these people do not even invest in any stock or mutual funds. They only invest in bank FDs. That is where they lose even more.
However, there are some who make a lot of money. I was told by a trader who took my course that there are two brothers in some town in Tamil Nadu who are making a killing trading Futures hedged with options. They are making a profit of almost 20-30 lakhs every month on a 1 crore account. Well that works out to a cool 30% return. That does not mean everyone can do it. They must be following a solid strategy and most importantly they are highly disciplined.
We will go to the topic soon but before that let me explain how these brother might have reached there.
1. First they got some education on trading.
2. Then they must have tested a few strategies that their system may have provided or they may have developed themselves.
3. These strategies may have been tested on paper or one or two lots max for at least 6 months.
4. Then once they got a strategy that suits their personality and trading style and also bring in good results they would have gradually started increasing the lot size of the strategies.
5. And then in few months time, a time comes when you finally see profits of lakhs a month. 🙂
Yep some knowledge, some hard work, and some discipline but see if you are highly disciplined and have a sound strategy making a lot of money from stock markets is not that difficult. But you need knowledge, patience and discipline – that’s the key.
So why am I telling you all this? Because the strategy we are going to learn in this article involves combination of Futures and Options.
The Ratio Put Selling Trade:
When your view is that the stock may remain range-bound, you can:
1. Sell/Write one Future, &
2. Sell/Write two ATM Puts.
Risk vs Reward:
See the image to understand:
As you can see the risk is unlimited to both sides. Frankly I do not like any trade that has unlimited risk. This trade has risk on both sides. In my book its not a good trade.
NOTE: If you have a job or business taking any trade with unlimited risk is NOT recommended. Why? Because you cannot monitor the markets 9-3. If some bad news comes while you are in an important meeting, a lot of money can be lost. On top of that your broker will call you and the only thing you will tell him at that point is to take the stop loss. By the way at that point what else can you do? But if you were trading full time may be you would have taken a stop loss much earlier. Still I would rather not suggest unlimited risk strategies. The reward is not worth the risk. Stay away. There are better trades. Just search my blog. 🙂 Or other blogs.
In my course the directional strategy is a beautiful combination of Futures and options but the hedge is such that there is no unlimited loss, in fact there is no need to take stop loss as the Max loss is so small that a trader can just leave the trade one full month to hit target. What are the chances that it will hit the target if you leave the trade till expiry? Well a lot.
For example on 6-Apr-2015 I had sold Nifty FUT APR 2015 at 8671.5, after that Nifty rallied almost 200 odd points but I did not take the stop loss as the position was hedged, now I am waiting for the profits to arrive. Even if it doesn’t I am OK as the loss I will take on expiry day will be small. But if Nifty falls even 100 points from here my trade will be in profit. What are the chances? A lot. I still have 15 days to go. 🙂
Lets do a real trade on Ratio Put Selling (Prices as on 14-Apr-2015):
Nifty Spot: 8834.00 (We treat 8800 as At The Money (ATM))
NIFTY Future 30Apr2015: 8855.00
NIFTY 30Apr2015 PE 8800.00: 75.00
The traders view is that Nifty may be range-bound or will fall slightly from here till expiry on 30-Apr-2015. The trader plays the ratio put selling.
Sells 1 lot of Nifty Future at 8855 and also Sells 2 lots of 8800 PE at 75.
Note: In such trades where the risk is unlimited and you cannot stop yourself trading, its highly recommended that you trade in 1 or 2 lots only. If you take a big risk and if Nifty really falls (your view is right) but falls too much suddenly you will have to take a huge loss. On the other hand if Nifty rallies, you still take a loss.
Now lets calculate the max profit and break even points.
The trade makes great profit if the stock stays at around 8800 till expiry or expires exactly at 8800. Lets calculate the profits.
Very Important Tip: Futures premium will vanish and it will show exact price of Nifty spot on expiry day. (This is a great reason to actually short futures and buy the stock in cash. This trade is known as arbitrage. In arbitrage some profits are guaranteed. Its very difficult to find stocks with very high Future premiums, otherwise no one would trade Nifty options. If you can make guaranteed 2% a month by arbitrage what is the need to take risk? The markets makers were quick to realize this so you will see that stock Futures do not have a very high premium. Nifty has, unfortunately you cannot buy shares of Nifty. Someone mailed me and asked if they can do the arbitrage with NiftyBeES. The answer is NO because Each NiftyBeES unit is 1/10th of the Nifty Index value, and Future is 1. So the whole trade will get very complex and unmanageable. If someone reading this has some experience in NiftyBeES please share in comments. Frankly I have never seen or read anywhere traders hedging Futures with NiftyBeES.)
Coming back. Nifty expires at 8800.
Profit from Futures: 8855-8800 = 55 points. 55*25 = 1375.
Both the Put options expire worthless. 75*2*25 = 3750.
Total profits: Rs.5125.00
ROI: Approx 14,000*3 will be blocked. (For each Future and option sell in Nifty approx 14k is blocked)
14,000*3 = 42000 = (5125/42000)*100 = 12.2% in less than 15 days amazing returns but it comes with unlimited risk, so trade with caution.
Calculating beak even points:
This is slightly difficult to calculate as two lots of options are sold.
On the up side both the Put options will expire worthless:
So the profits: ((75 * 25 ) + (75 * 25 )) = 3750.
Now the trader can take this as max loss.
3750/25 = 150
8855 + 150 = 9005.
So 9005 is our break even at the upside after this the trade starts losing money.
At 9005 the Future will lose: 8855 9005 = -150 * 25 = -3750.
Since both options expire worthless and trader makes 3750 from the put options this trade will break even at 9005.
On the down side:
If 9005-8800 = 205 points was our BE, it should be same on the downside as well.
8800 205 = 8595. This is our BE at the downside.
At 8595 the Future will make: 8855 – 8595 = 260 * 25 = 6500.
At 8595 the puts will be in the money:
8800 8595 = 205-75 = 130. So a loss of 130 points = -130*2*25 = 6500.
So at the downside 8595 is our break even. Below that the trade starts losing money.
Where to take a Stop Loss in Ratio Put Selling?
We just discussed the break even points if it is breached you should take a stop loss.
So in the current scenario the trade is safe from 9005 to 8595. Almost 400 points movement. Which means approximately every one times out of 2 the trade will hit stop loss.
Note that both 9005 and 8595 are Nifty Spot prices, not the Future price. Now tell me do you want to trade this?
Note: You may rollover the trade when SL is hit, but whether you make a profit or loss will depend on time taken to hit breakeven and volatility. If volatility has dropped and too much time has been taken to hit BE, on the upper side the trade may be in profit. In that case why should you rollover? On the lower side volatility may not have dropped, in fact increased and since falls are swift, the trade may be in loss. In that case you may rollover.
- Ratio Put Selling involves One Future Sell and Two ATM Puts Sell.
- It has a unlimited risk and limited reward. Unlimited risk trades need your full attention. Please do not attempt if you have a job.
- Its important that you calculate the break even points and take stop loss when its breached.
- You may rollover the trade once SL is hit. There is no need to rollover if the trade is in profit when SL is hit.
What do you do when you sell Future and its going against you? Do you hedge it or not? Please comment. Your questions and my answers will help other traders reading this.
You Can Read More On My Site
WhatsApp or Call me: 9051143004
If you have any question you can contact me.
You can read about me here and my trading mistakes here.
Dilip Shaw, Founder
Copyright Infringement: Any act of copying, reproducing or distributing any content in the site or newsletters, whether wholly or in part, for any purpose without my permission is strictly prohibited and shall be deemed to be copyright infringement.
INCOME DISCLAIMER: Any references in this site of income made by the traders are given to me by them either through Email or WhatsApp as a Thank You message. However every trade depends on the trader and his level of risk taking capability, knowledge and experience. Moreover stock market investments and trading are subject to market risks. Therefore there is no guarantee that everyone will achieve the same or similar results. My aim is to make you a better & disciplined trader with the stock trading and investing education and strategies you get from this website.
DISCLAIMER: I am NOT an Investment Adviser (IA). I am an Authorized Person (AP) of a Stock Broker. In other words I am a sub-broker. I DO NOT give tips or advisory services by SMS, Email, or WhatsApp or any other forms of social media. I strictly adhere to laws of my country. I only offer education for free on finance, risk management & investments in stock markets through the articles in this website. You must consult an authorized Investment Adviser (IA) or do thorough research before investing in any stock or derivative using any strategy given in this website. I am not responsible for any investment decision you take after reading any article in this website. Click here to read the disclaimer in full.