≡ Menu

Can You Hedge Nifty Future With Nifty BeES


One of my regular blog readers in USA asked a great question in the article hedging vs stop loss which is better: In simple language he asked if one can buy an Index Future and hedge it with buying Puts in its ETF?

In India that question converts to if you can buy Nifty Future and hedge it with buying put of any electronic trading fund that mimics Nifty like Nifty BeES.

Unfortunately we don’t have options trading on ETFs here in India. Even if it was done it does not make sense to hedge Nifty Future with and option of a Fund.

There is one major reason for it and that is one unit (or lot) of the ETF fund will never match one lot size of Nifty in terms of cash. It will almost always be very small in size in terms of total value in Rupees.

ETFs usually have very small cash size. There is a reason for it – so that even those with not much money to invest in stock markets may be able to participate in its growth. Like in most equity mutual funds in India you can start a SIP for Rs. 500 per month.

In the Goldman Sachs Nifty ETS Fund (an electronic trading scheme fund that mimics Nifty a.k.a Nifty BeES) the minimum investment is Rs. 10000/- and any additional investment thereof is Rs. 1000/- only. If options is allowed here the ticket size will be too small to hedge anything against Nifty.

According to NSE website: Nifty BeES trades on the Capital Market segment of NSE. Each Nifty BeES unit is 1/10th of the S&P CNX Nifty Index value. Nifty BeES units are traded and settled in dematerialised form like any other share in the rolling settlement.

So essentially if you hedge you are only hedging 1/10th of your trade. In simple language its not technically a hedge to hedge Nifty Futures with Nifty BeES.

I wrote the same reply to Michael:

Hope the article helps you trade profitably there in the USA.

To answer your question I am not comfortable hedging one instrument with another instrument even if they are related. That’s not real hedging. I also see that there is a huge difference between dollar value of one contract of NQ and dollar value of one contract of ETF. In fact there is BIG difference – the ratio of NQ:QQQ stands at 1:800 approx.

There is no way you can hedge it with buying cheaper puts of QQQ. Please remember whenever you hedge the dollar value of both contracts should be same. Agreed ETFs are cheaper but they will be helpless in case there is a crash. The kind of money you make from puts will be negligible.

If you really want to save money, then buy slightly out of the money puts. They will also give a great protection – but it starts only after some loss is taken. ATM options are costly but they start protecting from day 1. You lose some, you gain some – that’s the puzzle you need to solve.

In the US if you don’t know that volumes are so huge that even ETFs have options, commodities like Gold, Silver, Crude have options. There is LEAP that is options expiring after years – even they are highly traded.

From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LEAPS_(finance):

In finance, LEAPS (an acronym for Long Term Equity AnticiPation Security) are options of longer term until expiry than other, more common, options. LEAPS are available on approximately 2500 equities and 20 indexes. As with traditional short term options, LEAPS are available in two forms, calls and puts.

LEAPS were created relatively recently and typically extend for terms of 2 years out. Equity LEAPS always expire in January. For example, if today were November 2014, one could buy a Microsoft January call option that would expire in 2015, 2016, or 2017. The latter two are LEAPS.

In fact in US option spreads are traded as one single trade for the difference between them unlike in India where we have to trade two different legs and we are not sure exactly what points we are going get.

Trades are asking SEBI to at least block as margin the max loss that is possible in a debit or a credit spread, but for reasons better known to them they are still blocking full margin.

Update: Oct 30, 2019 – SEBI may lower margin requirements for hedged trades in F&O segment. Read more here – this is a good news if you have done my course:

https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/sebi-may-lower-margin-requirements-for-hedged-trades-in-fo-segment-4586591.html

For example if you buy an option for 10 and sell another OTM option for 5. In the US only 5+brokerage will be blocked as margin whereas here in India the brokers will ignore the buy and block full margin for the option sold.

SEBI’s reasoning is volumes. They say if any option goes deep in the money and there are less traders and the ask bid price has too much gap, the losses can be more than the max blocked. Unfortunately until this exists we have to trade whatever is given to us.

But once the rule changes we can trade many more lots with the same cash in our account. In that case the returns from the hedged trades will be even more. People who have taken my course can then make even more. 🙂

Please like & share my blog with your friends:

Hi, I am Dilip Shaw, owner of this website. I am a trader like you. I have been trading since 2007, but lost a lot of money till 2010. I then stopped trading and studied options like college exams. Started trading again from 2011 and never looked back since. I did a lot of research, read books and did countless paper-trading before being profitable. You can read about me here.

My conservative trading course since 2014 is helping many retail traders just like you who have a job or business make consistent profits like this:

What Traders Say About This Course
Testimonials Year 2015
Testimonials Year 2015 Page 2
Testimonials Year 2015 & 2016
Testimonials Year 2016
Testimonials Year 2017
Testimonials Year 2018
Testimonials Year 2019
Testimonials Year 2020 to 2023
What People Say Just After Reading My Course
Emotional Testimonial by a Young Woman Trader and Her Mother
One Of My Client Is Making Rs.25k Per Week
Difference Between Other Courses And Mine
What Others Charge for Courses

You can do this course from your home. Some traders make amazing profits like Rs. 16.26 lakhs profit in 5 days though results may differ for all.

This course helps you learn to trade conservative option strategies for monthly income. Once you finish the course you can start trading immediately. You can start trading from any day. No need to wait for expiry. You will make profits consistently.

This course is good if you have a regular job or business. You DO NOT NEED to monitor your trades every second.

What You Get?

Before reading please understand that for all 5 strategies, strike selection will be taught. Strike selection while trading Options is the most essential part to succeed.

You get two conservative non-directional strategies on options, one conservative stock option strategy and two conservative directional strategies on Future & Option combination.

Non directional trades are profitable 80% of the times and make 3-5% per trade (Results may vary).

Directional strategy makes money fast. It does not matter which side the stock moves. In fact you make more when you are wrong in the Future trade. 🙂 Some amazing profits possible here.

The stock option trade makes 30,000 in one trade and if SL is hit there is a way to recover losses plus make 30k in that trade.

Technical knowledge is NOT required. No need to monitor trades every second.

In the course you will learn how to select the strike prices. You learn when to trade, which strikes to sell which to buy, how much profit target you should be looking for, the best place to take stop loss and what to do after taking stop loss – means how to get that money back. The success rate is more than 80%.

Since trades are properly hedged there is no stress in trading my strategies.

I am very confident that you will make money trading my strategies. To help you succeed I offer few months support for FREE.

11 Reasons Why You Should Do The Course:
1. TA Knowledge NOT required
2. NO Software Required
3. Regular Monitoring NOT Required
4. Continue with Your Job
5. Do Course From Your Home
6. 100% Hedged
7. Stress-Free Trading
8. Not too much money needed to trade
9. Scaling Possible
10. One Time Fee
11. FREE Support For Months
To know more Call/SMS/WhatsApp me on 9051143004 or email me now. I know English and Hindi.

Read the details of the course here.

If you want to enroll for the course you can do so here.

P.S: So many years of trading has thought me one thing - it is always better to make small profits month after month, rather than lose money month after month trying to make too much money. It never happens. But small money accumulated month after month can become very big in only a few years.

Privacy Policy | Disclaimer

WhatsApp or Call me: 9051143004

If you have any question you can contact me.

You can read about me here and my trading mistakes here.

TheOptionCourse.com Copyright @ All Rights Reserved
Dilip Shaw, Founder

Copyright Infringement: Any act of copying, reproducing or distributing any content in the site or newsletters, whether wholly or in part, for any purpose without my permission is strictly prohibited and shall be deemed to be copyright infringement.

INCOME DISCLAIMER: Any references in this site of income made by the traders are given to me by them either through Email or WhatsApp as a Thank You message. However every trade depends on the trader and his level of risk taking capability, knowledge and experience. Moreover stock market investments and trading are subject to market risks. Therefore there is no guarantee that everyone will achieve the same or similar results. My aim is to make you a better & disciplined trader with the stock trading and investing education and strategies you get from this website.

DISCLAIMER: I am NOT an Investment Adviser (IA). I am an Authorized Person (AP) of a Stock Broker. In other words I am a sub-broker. I DO NOT give tips or advisory services by SMS, Email, or WhatsApp or any other forms of social media. I strictly adhere to laws of my country. I only offer education for free on finance, risk management & investments in stock markets through the articles in this website. You must consult an authorized Investment Adviser (IA) or do thorough research before investing in any stock or derivative using any strategy given in this website. I am not responsible for any investment decision you take after reading any article in this website. Click here to read the disclaimer in full.

About Brokers and Discount Brokers India
Hedging vs Stop Loss Which is Better

About the author: I started trading stock markets since 2007. However my first 3 years were losses. Then I dedicated almost 1 year on studying, researching, paper trading options and learned a lot in that time. Since 2011 I am trading Nifty options profitably. Call me if you need any help trading options on 9051143004.

{ 6 comments… add one }
  • Ishwar Mamnani July 25, 2015, 5:35 pm

    I believe currently one can hedge 1 short Nifty Futures contract by buying 50 Nifty BeES units. Also, cross margining benefits are available from the stock exchange for this trade. Please correct if I am mistaken.

    • Dilip Shaw July 25, 2015, 6:02 pm

      Ishwar,

      Thanks for the great comment. If you can elaborate it further that would be even better. For example if you short 1 Nifty Future and buy 50 Nifty BeES units and lets say your stop loss is 200 points which converts to 25*200 = 5000. How much profit will the 50 Nifty BeES contract make? These figures are important because frankly I have never looked into that direction. I am a firm believer of hedging my trade on the same stock. I know its simple and safe.

      I have no idea of the cross margin benefit between a Nifty and Nifty BeES hedge. If you have any link to share please do send.

      Please do reply it will benefit all the readers including me.

      Many Thanks.

  • Ishwar Mamnani July 25, 2015, 6:11 pm

    The Nifty Bees stock will also gain by approximately Rs 2000 (50 units X ~40/share). Please note that increase in Nifty BeES will not be exactly Rs 40 due to various factors like tracking error/ spreads on the trading price. Also, as it is an equity ETF, STT is 0 on the nifty bees buy leg and only 0.001 % on the nifty bees sell leg.

    Hope this clarifies.

    • Dilip Shaw July 25, 2015, 6:52 pm

      Thanks Ishwar, will look into this. I personally feel Nifty Bees is something that you should buy every month until you retire. Though I don’t do it, I know people having lots of Nifty Bees probably worth crores. 🙂 Nifty Bees in my view is not a hedging tool, but if its working for you its great.

  • Ishwar Mamnani July 25, 2015, 6:17 pm
    • Dilip Shaw July 25, 2015, 6:55 pm

      Thanks for the information. Will look into this, but I don’t understand why brokers do not advertise this. Learned something new today.
      Many Thanks.

Leave a Comment

Social Share Buttons and Icons powered by Ultimatelysocial